Unmasking Executive Education in Sub-Saharan Africa

Cathy pauses by the window of her fifth-floor office to look at the rain clouds gathering and the traffic beginning to build.  It is four o’clock in the afternoon and her boss has just walked in to ask for a ‘short’ team meeting. She is anxious; an important customer has just called to query some figures in his bank statement and wants it addressed by the end of the day.

A mother of two, Cathy has recently enrolled for an executive MBA programme at a local university. Her classes start at 5:30 p.m. and she knows only too well that she has to leave the office by 4:45 to beat the traffic. A few months earlier, during her performance review, her boss told her that she needed to improve her qualifications to advance further into management. But a colleague of hers, who got a promotion after completing an MBA, recently had a bad review. She wonders if taking the executive programme will be worth all the effort.

Moses1

Will Cathy’s investment in executive education improve her career prospects? Will it lead to a pay increase? And will her newly acquired skills improve her day-to-day job performance? In 2016, FSD Africa commissioned research to assess the impact of executive education in financial services firms and to help answer these questions.

On the subject of pay, it found that many employees with ExEd qualifications do not feel their salary is commensurate with their education, especially as many have had to pay fees to advance their studies. ExEd graduates do report, though, that they are more mobile in terms of career prospects than their peers. Importantly, managers respect the work of employees with ExEd qualifications, reporting that they perform well and are innovative – particularly in terms of applying the skills they acquired to problem solving.

Qualitative data from the report indicates that ExEd employees in financial services firms improve the image of their organisation and play a key role in shaping customer perceptions of it. What’s more, both employee and manager groups reported that ExEd is particularly effective in improving customer service skills – and therefore increasing customer satisfaction.

The research recommends changes in the delivery, scope and content of executive education, in order to address the needs of the financial sector. The most important of these is that ExEd should be more practical in nature, instead of focusing so heavily on theory. In addition, longitudinal research is necessary to measure the impact of executive education programmes on students and organisations. And lastly, improvement is needed in performance measurement within financial services firms, in order to better demonstrate the link between ExEd and performance, pay and mobility.

Click here to download the full report: ‘The Impact of Executive Education in sub-Saharan Africa’.

Written by Dr. Moses Ochieng, Consultant-Professional Skills Development, FSD Africa

Comments

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.

  • Dr. Ochieng, your insightful portraying of the case is highly appreciated. The case is practically presented. I have gone through the summary of the report but I request to make it quite simple. Borrowing heavily from the book of Managers not MBA:- A Hard Look at the Soft Practice of Managing and Management Development by Henry Mintzberg. The excerpts of the book can be read through https://www.bkconnection.com/static/Managers-Not-MBAs-EXCERPT.pdf. The author argues that there is no right way of training the wrong people. His arguments challenges the selection process to the ExEd, the administration of the ExEd programmes among other challenges .

    A walk through institutions offering the ExEd program appear ill prepared i.e. using theoritical lecturers (persons without industry working experince on the subject matter) to facilitate course. Due to astronomical costs of the programs quality of students academic work is potentially being overlooked. Country or industry myths make the situation worse. In some industries, your worth is not driven by your professional output but by number of academic and professional certificates you hold.

    It is my suggestions that value of ExEd should not be dimished but right and effective approach must be adopted. Otherwise the logic behind ExEd program is simple. It should commence by skill gap identification, development plan hence ExEd requires true partnerships of the stakeholders